Health Insurance Trends for 2026: What Nonprofits Need to Know

Health insurance feels like it changes every year, and many nonprofits are already trying to figure out what 2026 might look like. Costs keep shifting, new rules pop up, and employees expect more support from their benefits. It can feel like a lot to track, especially if you do not have a large HR team.

Here are a few trends that are starting to take shape, along with what they might mean for your organization.

Costs Are Still Rising, But Not as Sharply

Premiums will likely continue to go up, although some early reports suggest the increases might not be as steep as the last few years. Insurers are focusing more on preventive care and programs that keep people healthier rather than reacting once someone is already sick.

For nonprofits, this usually shows up in the form of wellness incentives, easier access to routine care, and more reminders that early checkups cost less than late interventions.

Mental Health Support Keeps Expanding

One thing that almost every insurer seems to agree on is the need for stronger mental health coverage. Employees are asking for it, and nonprofits see the effects of stress more than most industries. Expect to see more teletherapy options, lower barriers to treatment, and plans that connect mental and physical health instead of treating them separately.

If your team handles emotionally heavy work, this is a good time to see if your benefits are meeting their needs.

Virtual Care Is Now Just Health Care

Telehealth is not viewed as a backup plan anymore. Many doctors now split their time between in-person visits and virtual appointments. Some insurers are even promoting digital-first care, where employees talk to a virtual provider before deciding if an office visit is necessary.

For nonprofits with staff in multiple locations, this can make care easier and faster. It often helps reduce missed work time too.

Employees Want Clearer Information

Health care costs can feel mysterious, and the government has been pushing insurers to make pricing more transparent. Because of that, you might notice more tools that show cost comparisons, plan breakdowns, and even hospital rating sheets.

The tricky part is getting employees to use them. A little education during open enrollment can go a long way and can help keep your organization’s costs under control.

More Interest in Personalized Benefits

Nonprofits with diverse teams are starting to look at benefits that employees can customize. Some employers are exploring ICHRAs, where the organization gives each person a set budget and lets them choose their own plan.

This approach does not work for everyone, but it can be a good fit for groups with staff in different counties, different age ranges, or different family setups. It requires thoughtful communication to make sure no one feels confused or overwhelmed.

What This Means for Your Nonprofit

The biggest takeaway is simple. Health insurance is not getting any easier to navigate, but nonprofits do not have to figure it out alone. Reviewing your plan once a year and asking a few honest questions about what your team actually needs can help avoid surprises later on.

At CalNonprofits Insurance Services, we help organizations sort through changes like these so you can choose a plan that fits your people and your budget. If your renewal is coming up, we can walk you through what to expect for 2026.

‍